Sunday, April 29, 2012

A Hard-Learned Lesson

You know, some situations just don’t lend themselves to kink. I learned this recently, the hard way.

I write erotic books for a living, so it should make sense that I’d be able to heat up a sensual category romance for reissue. It DID make sense with four of my five New York-published books, but the process just wouldn’t work for the fifth one, no matter how many weeks/months I spent trying to turn it into an erotic romance.
 
At first I didn’t understand why. The hero and heroine enjoyed plenty of hot, imaginative sex, way more than in most category romances. No, there were no ménages, BDSM scenes or kinky dream sequences, but that has been the case in several of my better selling, award-winning original erotic romances, as well as in my four previously revised reissues.
 
I originally proposed the book that just wouldn't turn erotic for Berkley’s limited “Quilting” series, though it was published by Kensington in its short-lived Bouquet line. The quilt-maker heroine was too innocent. The hero, a self-made millionaire seeking to rediscover his roots, was Alpha in the bedroom but a pussycat everywhere else. Worse, the story premise and setting didn't lend themselves to erotic romance. I thought about adding some kinky sex between the hero and his former fiancée…creating a hot, dream sequence between the heroine and her dead fiancé in which she didn’t wait for a wedding that never happened…making the heroine sexually repressed until the hero takes control, as in BDSM light. None of these options made sense for the characters or their worlds.

This wasn't the type of book I've been writing over the past few years. Still, I liked the story and wanted readers who missed it during its brief time in a poorly distributed category line. I'd spun wheels revising it, getting  rid of a lot of problems I hadn’t recognized eleven years ago when I first wrote the book. Because I believe my readers expect my sex scenes to be graphic and detailed, I beefed them up but tried to stay within what I thought Althea and Jared actually would do. 

The result is MOUNTAIN HEAT, a very sexy conventional romance with a folksy tone befitting a country quilt-maker and a guy searching for his long-lost roots, coming soon from Ellora's Cave. I hope  readers won’t be disappointed that the story’s not quite as sizzling as most of my more recent books. I just may write a couple more super-hot but not exactly erotic romances because I occasionally like the one man, one woman scene, even though it seems a little old-fashioned in a romance world of ménage a trois, voyeurism, BDSM, shapeshifting, and so on.

What do you all think? Do you sometimes go for erotic romance "Light", or does your taste always run more toward the no-holds-barred, completely uninhibited tales that leave you panting for your guy/toys/whatever more than sighing over the happily-ever-after conclusion of lovers whose lust is tempered by conventional, vanilla love?
I'll be picking a winner at the end of the month from all the comments posted here. Prize will be a download of the winner's choice of any of my published books, to be announced on Twitter and my Facebook page.
Ann Jacobs
Follow me on Twitter: @authrannjacobs




6 comments:

Fiona McGier said...

Actually "vanilla erotic" is what I write, and what I look for to read. My brother's wife once told me that since I write such boring vanilla stuff, I shouldn't expect to sell much. Thanks for the support.

In the town I live in, Evangelical USA, I could be burned at the stake for what I write! And I sub in high schools during the day, but unlike Judy Mays with her kerfuffle earlier this year, I don't have tenure or a union behind me, so if word got out what my pen name is, I could be summarily dismissed.

I guess once person's "too hot" is another person's "yawn". I fall somewhere in-between. But hey, there's room for all of us, and hopefully readers for all of us!

Fiona McGier said...

Oh, and I had the same kind of problem with my last book, since there were 2 heroes...I knew readers would want a menage scene, but the characters themselves (2 of them anyway) didn't lend themselves to that kind of action. So I agonized over it for weeks. I think I finally did a good job in resolving the issue with a scene that was easy to write once I figured out how.

Tina Donahue said...

I find I run between the erotic romance with a lot of heart and the no-holds barred kind. Depends upon the stories, the characters. For me, they have to find their own level.

Adele Dubois said...

I definitely enjoy both reading and writing stories of varied heat levels. I'd get bored with one type of story.

Best of luck with your release!

~Adele

Cathy M said...

Hi Ann,

While I tend to read more erotic romances than any other, I do enjoy a lighter fare sometimes.

If the storytelling and characters work for me, then I have no problem with vanilla sex scenes, and totally get why it might be just what suits the characters.

I will be looking forward to reading your upcoming release.

caity_mack at yahoo dot com

flchen1 said...

Ann, I read a range of heat levels (from inspirational to bedroom-door WIDE open), and don't always feel a good story has to be incredibly hot. I think I appreciate a story where the heat level fits the characters and their journey, and one where I feel the emotional connection between the characters, in and out of bed.